Case study · Carpe · Experiential

Carpe: how “Can I smell your armpit?” became a paid-ready ad

We asked NYC strangers one weird question, tested the video on people who don't follow us, and handed Carpe a proven ad before they spent a dollar on it.

Opening frame of the Carpe video: a stranger on a New York sidewalk under the on-screen text “Asking Strangers If I Can Smell Their Armpits”
The opening frame. The hook is on screen from second one.
1.17M
views
99.8%
non-followers
48.4K
shares
7,950
saves

01 · Where we started

Fun to watch isn't enough

Our first round for Carpe was challenge-style videos. They hooked well, but they didn't convert. People watched for the fun and never got to why Carpe. The next concept had to do both: stop the scroll and sell the product inside the story.

02 · How we came up with it

Three questions we ask before every shoot

1

What experience does Carpe's audience want to have?

A spontaneous NYC afternoon with a stranger: the awkward, funny kind of moment people send to their friends.

2

What's a crazy hook that 60%+ of people will watch?

Walk up to strangers and ask, “Can I smell your armpit?” It's uncomfortable, and everyone wants to see who says yes.

3

How does the product fit inside the experience?

Carpe is the reason the question makes sense. The woman who finally says yes recognizes it (“Oh, Carpe”), and from there it's the ferry and lunch together.

The stranger who said yes, on the ferry
“Got rejected 10 times before someone finally said yes.”

That became the caption. Everyone on camera is a real stranger. No actors.

03 · Value before second 40

Entertaining isn't enough: the why-Carpe lands before second 40

Our first Carpe videos entertained but didn't convert. That taught us that a video can't just be entertaining to perform on paid. There has to be real value behind why Carpe.

In our experience, even when a video bangs, most people drop off by second 30–40. So we front-load the value, and here it comes from the stranger herself, not from a voiceover:

  1. 0:00The hook: “I will buy you lunch if I can smell your armpit.” The first few people say no.
  2. 0:11“I work for a deodorant company.” She answers before he says the name: “Oh, Carpe… I love Carpe.”
  3. 0:17She picks the plan, a ferry to Red Hook, and he tags along.
  4. 0:29On the ferry: “I do really love Carpe, I use it every day.”
  5. 0:35She guesses his scent, “Ocean Storm?”, and she's right. She knows the product.
  6. 0:40By now a real customer has told you why she uses Carpe, while the story is still going.
The stranger saying “I love Carpe” on the sidewalk
0:15 · “I love Carpe.”
The stranger on the ferry saying she uses Carpe every day
0:30 · “I use it every day.”

04 · How we tested it

Trial Reels first, paid second

Every video we make goes out as an Instagram Trial Reel before the brand spends a dollar on it. Trial Reels are shown only to people who don't follow the account, which makes them the closest free read on how a cold paid audience will react.

1

Post as a Trial Reel

2

Read the numbers

3

Check them against our benchmarks

4

Send the winners to paid

05 · Results

The results so far

Instagram insights, Nov 17, 2026

1,168,301
views
889,659
viewers
99.8%
of views from non-followers
85,348
interactions from 54,575 accounts
27,900
likes
48,389
shares
7,950
saves
490
comments
315
new follows

Shares nearly doubled likes. People sent it to friends far more often than they tapped like, and every share was free extra reach.

06 · How we read it for paid

Organic signals as a paid forecast

A Trial Reel has no CPM or CTR, so each organic number stands in for a paid one.

Shares → CTR & free reach

~41 per 1,000 views

Someone acted on it and brought more people to it for free.

Likes → CPM

~24 per 1,000 views

Broad approval tends to mean cheaper delivery.

Saves → Purchase intent

~7 per 1,000 views

“I want to come back to this.”

Skip rate → Hook rate

Does the opening stop strangers?

Watch time → Hold rate

Does the story keep them?

These are our internal stand-ins, not exact equivalents. When paid results come in, those win.

07 · What happened next

From test to paid

  • Carpe wanted it live right away as a collab post, and they're running it as a paid ad.
  • Their one note was to cut the product pop-ups: “the ad feels SO REAL until this point.” We sent a clean cut.
  • Five more videos with the same hook are in production.
  • Watch the video on Instagram →

Want an IRL video your audience actually wants to watch?

Let's build something real for your brand.